SureMembers vs Wishlist Members: which extension to choose?
Are you planning to create a membership site on WordPress, and wondering which extension is perfect? If you’re hesitating between SureMembers and Wishlist Members, two of the most famous and effective plugins, this article is for you. Discover the features, advantages and disadvantages of each so you can make an informed choice.
We offer a comparative analysis of SureMembers and Wishlist Members, two must-have solutions for creating, administering and marketing online memberships with WordPress. Examine their features, pricing, ease of use, and compatibility with other applications.
Whether you’re a content creator, trainer, coach, entrepreneur or enthusiast, here you’ll find the key information you need to decide which extension to opt for in 2024. Find out together SureMembers vs Wishlist Members: the best choice for 2024.
SureMembers overview
SureMembers is an essential WordPress plugin that simplifies the creation, management and monetization of membership sites. Whether you want to restrict access to articles, videos, podcasts, online courses or digital products, SureMembers has you covered. It offers customizable access levels, flexible payments and seamless integration with other popular WordPress tools.
Key features
Explore SureMembers’ promising features:
- Easy content paywalls: Protect your exclusive content in just a few clicks. Choose which pages and articles to restrict, and use shortcodes to secure specific sections.
- Content drip feed: Schedule the progressive distribution of your content to boost member engagement and loyalty.
- Customized access rules: Meticulously customize access to your content according to member groups, either by content type, category or author.
- Secure digital downloads: Ensure the protection of your downloadable files, making them accessible only to authorized members and controlling their use.
- Visibility of menu items: adapt the visibility of your menu to the profile of your members, offering personalized, enhanced navigation.
Sell online courses: Develop and market your online courses, easily integrate educational plug-ins, and offer your students a unique experience.
Ease of use and integration
Setting up SureMembers is child’s play. Install and activate the plugin quickly, configure your member site with an intuitive wizard, and benefit from attentive customer support and comprehensive documentation for any questions you may have. What’s more, SureMembers works perfectly with your favorite WordPress plugins and tools, such as page builders (Elementor, Beaver Builder, etc.), form plugins (Gravity Forms, WPForms, etc.), calendar plugins (The Events Calendar, etc.) and customer support solutions (FluentCRM, MailPoet, etc.).
Pricing options
SureMembers offers three annual plans to suit your needs:
- Starter Plan: $99 per year for one site, including all essential features, updates and support.
- Pro Plan: $199 per year for three sites, including Starter Plan benefits plus premium integrations.
- Agency Plan: $299 per year for ten sites, offering all the services and benefits of the previous plans.
What’s more, SureMembers offers a 30-day money-back guarantee if the plugin doesn’t live up to your expectations.
Wishlist Members overview
Wishlist Members is a powerful WordPress plugin designed to help you build distinctive and secure members’ areas on your blog or website. It opens up the possibility of creating a multitude of membership levels and limiting access to content based on user subscriptions.
Key features
Discover the main features of Wishlist Members below:
- Advanced content protection: Effectively protect different types of content, including pages, articles, categories, comments, files, RSS feeds and more. Use shortcodes to secure specific sections of your content.
- Scheduled content delivery: Offer your content to your members in a progressive way by establishing delivery rules based on registration date, access level or duration. This increases member engagement and enhances the value of your content.
- Unlimited access levels: Create as many access levels as you need, configurable to your preferences. Options include free, paid, one-time or recurring payment, defined or unlimited duration, and more.
- Customized access paths: Personalize your members’ routes by allowing them to change access levels automatically or manually. Ideal for structuring learning itineraries and proposing special offers or renewals.
- Member dashboard: Provide a personalized space where users can manage their profile, subscription, passwords and downloads. You can also display targeted messages according to their level of access.
Digital product sales: Wishlish Members makes it easy to sell digital products via WordPress plugins such as Easy Digital Downloads and WooCommerce. Manage specific customer access, offer discounts, coupons and bonuses to enrich their experience.
Ease of use and integration
Wishlist Members stands out for its ease of use and integration. Install and activate the plugin quickly, and configure your members’ area with the help of a step-by-step guide.
Access comprehensive documentation and video tutorials for further assistance.
The plugin works seamlessly with existing WordPress tools, including :
- Page creation plugins: Compatible with Elementor, Beaver Builder, Divi, Thrive Architect, etc., to design attractive, personalized pages.
- Forms plugins: Integrate with Gravity Forms, WPForms, Formidable Forms, etc., for customized registration and contact forms.
- Calendar plugins: Combine with The Events Calendar, Event Espresso, EventON, etc., to organize and manage exclusive events for your members.
Customer support plugins: Use with FluentCRM, WP Fusion, MailPoet, etc., for optimal customer relationship management, emailing and automation.
Pricing options
Wishlist Members offers four annual pricing plans, depending on the number of sites on which you wish to activate the plugin:
- Basic Plan: $149.50 per year for one site, including all basic functions, updates and standard support.
- Plan Plus: $249.50 per year for two sites, all-inclusive plus advanced integrations, priority support and CourseCure plugin.
- Pro Plan: $349.50 per year for five sites, with premium integrations, premium support and CourseCure included.
Elite Plan: $1,199.50 per year for five sites, offering all the benefits of the previous plans, plus integrations with Keap and Recurly.
This offer is complemented by a 14-day money-back guarantee if you are not completely satisfied.
Comparison: SureMembers vs Wishlist Members
After a detailed review of SureMembers’ and Wishlist Members’ key features, we’re now going to put them head to head on several crucial aspects. We’ll examine which solution offers the best integration, ease of use, value for money, and customer support.
Easy integration with existing tools
While SureMembers and Wishlist Members both boast excellent compatibility with must-have WordPress tools and plugins (such as page builder, form builder, calendar builder and support plugins), SureMembers stands out for its direct integration with SureTriggers. This tool not only allows you to create automations but also custom integrations with hundreds of web services, offering greater flexibility and more integration options than Wishlist Members.
Ease of use for both administrators and users
Both solutions are remarkably user- and administrator-friendly, supported by step-by-step guides, comprehensive documentation and video tutorials. They also allow you to customize pages and dashboards for members, using the page builder plugins of your choice. However, SureMembers’ interface stands out for its more contemporary and intuitive design, both for the administration (back-end) and the end-user (front-end), offering a superior user experience to Wishlist Members.
Value for money
Both solutions offer different annual pricing plans based on the number of application sites. While Wishlist Members is positioned at a premium by offering more access levels and premium integrations, SureMembers presents a more affordable offering while including a generous number of essential features and better integration. Choosing the best value will therefore depend on your specific needs and budget. Note that SureMembers offers a 30-day money-back guarantee, compared with 14 days for Wishlist Members, giving you the opportunity to experiment with less risk.
| Plan | SureMembers | Wishlist Members |
|---|---|---|
| Plan de Base | 99 $ par an pour un site | 149,50 $ par an pour un site |
| Plan Intermédiaire | 199 $ par an pour trois sites | 249,50 $ par an pour deux sites |
| Plan Avancé | 299 $ par an pour dix sites | 349,50 $ par an pour cinq sites |
| Plan Premium | 1 199,50 $ par an pour cinq sites |
Support and community
Reactive and efficient customer support is offered by both extensions, accessible via email or chat. They also both benefit from a committed community on social networks, forums and Facebook groups. Nevertheless, with a longer presence on the market and a more established reputation, Wishlist Members enjoys greater credibility and inspires more trust, giving it a slight advantage in terms of support and community belonging.
Find this article useful? Pin it on Pinterest! And share it on other networks, thank you.
Conclusion
If you’re tempted by the idea of creating a membership site with WordPress and are hesitating between SureMembers and Wishlist Members, this article should have provided you with the necessary clarification.
SureMembers and Wishlist Members, two premium WordPress extensions, give you the power to design, administer and market online subscriptions. They stand out for their advanced capabilities, ease of use and integration, as well as efficient customer support.
SureMembers stands out for its contemporary design, flexible integration capability and attractive cost. Wishlist Members, on the other hand, stands out for its longevity, reputation and ability to manage an unlimited number of access levels.
Your decision will be based on your specific requirements, your ambitions and your budget. Opting for one or the other will give you satisfaction.
Don’t delay in creating your WordPress membership site. SureMembers’ and Wishlist Members’ refund policies allow you to try their services risk-free. What’s more, our team is here to guide you every step of the way.
Choose SureMembers or Wishlist Members and Create Your WordPress Member Site
Responses